Why Australia should NOT become a Republic

I have a confession to make and I make no excuse for it.
In fact, my heart skips a beat and a little wave of excitement swells through me when I read headlines such as, ‘Prince Harry set to marry’.

You see, I love the royal family. Everything about the British monarchy fascinates me; a royal wedding that drags me out of bed at some ungodly hour totally pulls at my heart strings, or the birth of another cute prince or princess just makes me gush with excitement, and who doesn’t love a bit of royal scandal from time to time.

Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip

There are plenty of reasons not to care, but there are plenty of reasons to care and that’s why Australia should not become a republic.

The Australian Republican Movement held a referendum in 1999, and 55 per cent voted against Australia becoming a republic that would be headed by a president and cut ties with the British crown and the Westminster system.

So why are we still talking about this issue 18 years later when we live in the most beautiful country in the world with a traditional system that already works?

Can we address more important issues like the soaring prices of electricity bills? Or question why some young Australians face the possibility of living with their parents longer because of the current housing affordability crisis?

Unless you’re living under a rock or totally oblivious to what’s happening in the world right now, you’d know that America is a republic with their current President possessing incredible political power. The Australian Republican Movement defend this argument by stating that America is a completely different systemized republic and that an Australian republic would keep the same parliamentary democracy it already has, with the advantage of an Australian head of state to represent this great country.

I’m not buying it.

The Australian Republican Movement also gives a range of reasons why it’s time for Australia to stand on its own two feet which includes the following:

  • An Australian head of state will put Australia first – the Queen or King of England will never be able to represent us properly. I disagree: Queen Elizabeth has done a fine job until now and I question if some Australian politicians genuinely represent us properly!
  • We’ll be able to choose an Australian as our head of state instead of being told which English person we have to have. I counter that: The system has worked mighty fine until now and we all have witnessed in recent times in the US how much havoc a presidential election can cause.
  • Our constitution will be 100% Australian and independent of other countries. I counter that too: I rather like and appreciate being part of the Commonwealth realms, it gives me a sense of security and surety to march alongside other countries, you never know when you may need your allies help.
  • We’ll have a head of state that can represent Aussie values – mateship, equality and fair go – more than a foreign royal family ever could. Hmmm: Didn’t the Australian government recently announce a postal plebiscite costing millions of taxpayer funds to legalise same-sex marriage when England passed the legislation in 2014?

I’m still not buying it.

All those reasons have not convinced me to vote YES on Australia becoming a republic, simple as that.

There is a civil war in Syria, North Korea and its nuclear missile threats are no secret, Australia is tackling an epidemic of the drug ice and headlines are constantly filled with bad news. At a time of uncertainty that’s consuming many parts of the world, including our great southern land, becoming a republic may be an option one day but I just hope it’s not in my lifetime.

So until then, I will eagerly wait for another grand royal wedding and prepare myself for that early sunrise wake-up call to watch Prince Harry get married. One can only hope.


0 comments on “Why Australia should NOT become a Republic

  • Avatar

    You do realise when Queen Liz kicks the bucket we’re going to have to change all our money right?? And Prince Charles isn’t getting any younger, so it won’t be long until we’ll have to change it all again when Prince William becomes King.

    Plus, the Monarchy hasn’t really been “good so far”. The 1975 Constitutional Crisis is a prime example of that.

    It would be best for our country to become a republic sooner rather than later. But don’t worry, Im sure you’ll still be able to watch all those royal weddings.

  • Avatar

    When you think about it we will have to change the Australian flag and the money because they have the queens face on them. So I think we should not become a Repblic.

  • Avatar

    I agree with you.
    People say that Australia should be a republic so that as people, we can have the ultimate power.
    Now that just sounds greedy to me. Is everything really about power? Can we not just accept all that Britain has done for Australia as a whole, and thank them for establishing our country?
    Above all this, though, we should be trusting in God as the true power of our nation, not in governments big or small, Australian or British.

  • Avatar

    Australia Should Become a Republic! I believe that Australia should be and independent country, and we should not have to follow some King or Queen from a foreign country. The Head of State should be an Australian citizen, chosen by Australians. We should not be told who we have to follow and listen to. That choice should be Australians and Australian alone. The crown should not be claimed by someone just because they were born into a royal family. And plus, Who knows Australia better than an Australian himself.

  • Avatar

    It isn’t helpful, bb. It’s nonsense. (Point 1) If the queen has done a good job for Australia, it’s mainly because she’s stayed away – except when invited here to do something we’re perfectly capable of doing ourselves. However I note her first loyalty is to her own nation and her own legacy. This was made clear when she put an embargo on OUR Commonwealth records under the guise of ‘private letters’ i.e. presumably letters that are none of our business. Fortunately the High Court of Australia saw it differently. (Point 2) No republic supporter I know wants a US style republic with an executive president. Let alone their complicated, state-by-state pre-selection method for selecting candidates. There are many examples of parliamentary republics which manage to select their heads of state with out all the massive expense and hoopla which accompanies US elections. (Point 3) Most Commonwealth countries are already republics and nobody has suggested leaving the Commonwealth of Nations when we become a republic. Plus the Commonwealth club is not associated with a defence treaty. (Point 4) If the writer doesn’t approve of the current federal government and their handling of the marriage equality legislation (long, drawn out and lots of stalling tactics) then vote them out at the next election. This is what federal elections are for. As for civil wars, corruption and all the other problems, retaining a foreign monarch has not solved any of these problems. Australia will always have challenges but this should not stop an independent nation like Australia having its own official HoS.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Dscribe

Dscribe showcases the work of Deakin University’s journalism students. The opinions contained in Dscribe stories are that of the individual, and not Deakin University. If you believe that any of the material on this website infringes on your rights, click here: COPYRIGHT